New Zealand Seeks Fair Treatment for Dairy Exporters by Canada

New Zealand Seeks Fair Treatment for Dairy Exporters by Canada

New Zealand has escalated its ongoing dairy trade dispute with Canada, triggering mandatory negotiations under the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP) framework. This step follows a Panel of Arbitrators ruling in September 2023, which found that Canada breached its trade obligations by restricting New Zealand’s dairy exports. Trade and Agriculture Minister Todd McClay announced that despite the ruling, Canada has failed to comply, prompting New Zealand to formally request negotiations. The negotiations must begin within 15 days of the notification, as stipulated by the CPTPP’s dispute settlement process.

New Zealand Seeks Fair Treatment for Dairy Exporters
New Zealand’s request for formal negotiations stems from Canada’s failure to comply with the September 2023 ruling that determined Canada had violated its CPTPP obligations by blocking New Zealand dairy exports. According to Trade and Agriculture Minister Todd McClay, New Zealand expects its trading partners to honor the commitments outlined in trade agreements, ensuring that its exporters receive fair and equitable treatment. “Canada is not doing that with respect to the dairy quotas that were negotiated and agreed upon with New Zealand,” McClay stated, emphasizing that the issue pertains to Canada’s refusal to uphold its end of the agreement.

The matter has now progressed to a formal stage, where New Zealand is demanding that Canada open its markets in accordance with the agreed dairy quotas, a key element of the original CPTPP negotiations.

Mandatory Negotiations Under the CPTPP Framework
Under the CPTPP’s dispute settlement framework, the notification by New Zealand triggers a requirement for mandatory negotiations to begin within 15 days. This process aims to resolve trade disputes between member countries without escalating to more severe trade penalties. The move is seen as a formal step toward compelling Canada to abide by its trade obligations and address the concerns of New Zealand’s dairy exporters.

The CPTPP agreement, a trade pact between 11 Pacific Rim countries, is designed to promote free trade and investment across key industries, including agriculture. The dairy sector, a crucial part of New Zealand’s economy, benefits significantly from the free-market access promised under the CPTPP, which is why the current impasse with Canada is particularly contentious.

Canada’s Dairy Quota Restrictions: A Breach of Trade Obligations
The Panel of Arbitrators ruling in September found that Canada had breached its obligations by imposing unfair restrictions on New Zealand’s access to the Canadian dairy market. These restrictions specifically related to dairy quotas, which limit the volume of dairy products that can be exported to Canada. The quotas were a key aspect of the CPTPP negotiations, and New Zealand argues that Canada’s failure to adhere to these quotas has unfairly disadvantaged its exporters.

By blocking New Zealand dairy products, Canada has effectively undermined the spirit of the CPTPP agreement, which seeks to ensure fair and reciprocal trade among its member nations.

New Zealand’s Pursuit of Compliance and Market Access
New Zealand is determined to ensure compliance with the CPTPP agreement and protect the interests of its dairy industry. Minister McClay underscored New Zealand’s commitment to using all available mechanisms within the trade agreement to secure fair access to the Canadian market. He reiterated that the government’s priority is to safeguard the livelihoods of New Zealand exporters, many of whom rely heavily on the dairy sector’s international market access.

The formal negotiations that will soon begin are part of New Zealand’s broader strategy to hold its trade partners accountable and ensure the rules-based international trading system functions as intended. New Zealand remains hopeful that a resolution can be reached without further escalation but is prepared to take additional steps if necessary.

What’s at Stake for New Zealand’s Dairy Industry?
The New Zealand dairy industry, which is a cornerstone of the nation’s economy, relies on international trade agreements like the CPTPP to ensure access to key global markets. Canada’s restrictions on dairy exports have created a significant barrier to market entry for New Zealand dairy producers, affecting their revenues and growth opportunities.

With consolidated dairy exports forming a substantial portion of New Zealand’s export economy, securing unhindered market access is essential. This dispute with Canada, if not resolved, could have lasting implications for New Zealand’s broader trade relationships within the CPTPP and beyond.

General: